NUI Maynooth

NUIM ePrints and eTheses Archive

NUIM Library

Betwixt Principle and Practice: Tara Ross's Defense of the Electoral College. Reviewing: Enlightened Democracy: The Case for the Electoral College (World Ahead Publishing 2004)

Tillman, Seth Barrett (2005) Betwixt Principle and Practice: Tara Ross's Defense of the Electoral College. Reviewing: Enlightened Democracy: The Case for the Electoral College (World Ahead Publishing 2004). New York University Journal of Law and Liberty, 1. pp. 922-934.

[img] Download (782kB)

Abstract

Tara Ross has taken on a herculean task: an exposition of and a defense of the electoral college, in conjunction with a defense of prevailing state statutory and customary presidential election processes, including: first-past-the-post, winner-take-all with regard to appointing electors. It is a valiant, romantic, Don Quixote like effort. But in the end: the windmill still wins. It always does. Her explanation of prevailing practices falls short of the mark. And this I suggest might be a sign that the system is too complex and unwieldy. Ross also defends the electoral college for consistently producing the right winner, notwithstanding 1876 and 2000 where the electoral college winner (under the final tally) had fewer popular votes. But this defense, so common among defenders of the electoral college, fails to recognize that many states historically were rotten boroughs where those with the de jure and de facto vote controlled the whole state's slate of electors. So the if-it-ain't-really-really-broke-let's-not-fix-it-Burkean position is not so clear. Lastly, Ross's defense of the electoral college, rooted in federalism and states' rights concerns seems, to this reviewer at any rate, somewhat untethered from the actual details of the electoral college she seeks to defend.

Item Type: Article
Keywords: democracy; republic; the Federalist Papers; electoral college;
Subjects: Social Sciences > Law
Item ID: 2937
Depositing User: Seth Tillman
Date Deposited: 12 Jan 2012 10:24
Journal or Publication Title: New York University Journal of Law and Liberty
Publisher: New York University School of Law
Refereed: No
URI:

    Repository Staff Only(login required)

    View Item Item control page

    Document Downloads

    More statistics for this item...